Disruption claims in construction
In construction contracts, the term 'disruption' refers to a loss of productivity due to a hindrance or interruption of the progress of the construction works which reduces the rate of efficiency.
If disruption is caused by the employer, the contractor may have grounds to seek compensation. Disruption, and claims arising to try and recoup losses incurred from it, are common on construction projects, particularly on larger and more complex projects.
The difference between disruption and delay is that the latter relates to lateness rather than productivity, although they can often be related. Delays can cause disruptions, and vice versa. Despite their inter-relation, they require a different approach to assessing claims.
When evaluating claims for delay, the terms of the specific contract are the usual starting point, and evidence is required that certain circumstances caused the delay. The terms of the contract are less useful when evaluating disruption claims. Instead, the contractor must provide reasonable evidence that:
- Progress of the works has been disrupted.
- Which element of the works and which trades have been disrupted, why losses occurred, and so on.
- The disruption incurred additional costs.
- The cause of the disruption constitutes a breach of contract.
Evidence will normally take the form of documented records demonstrating that disruption caused losses. However, this can prove difficult as the contractor can often not detect disruption until after it has occurred. In addition, isolating the loss of productivity to the cause of the disruption can be difficult as it may coincide with several other factors, and the effect of the disruption may be hidden by other issues.
Several methods can be used to estimate loss in relation to disruption, including:
- Measured mile analysis: Compares actual labour performance between two periods – a normal measured mile period and an impacted period.
- Baseline productivity analysis: A more conservative estimate used when an unimpacted section of the works is too difficult to isolate.
- Earned value analysis: Compares the amount and cost of work that was planned to have been done by a particular stage with the amount that has actually been done and what it has actually cost.
NB The term ‘disruption’ can also refer to the impact of new technologies and techniques on an industry. For more information, see Construction is an industry ripe for tech disruption.
Anticipate, react, recover; Resilient infrastructure systems, published by the National Infrastructure Commission in May 2020, defines disruption as: ‘A disturbance which interrupts the usual functioning of an infrastructure system or service, and its impacts.’
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings
Featured articles and news
The continued ISG fall out, where to go?
Support for ISG contractors, companies and employees.
New HES national centre for traditional building retrofit
Announced as HES publishes survey results which reveal strong support for retrofit.
Retrofit of Buildings, a CIOB Technical Publication
Expected to become one of the largest activities in the global construction industry.
The ECA industry focus video channel
Keeping update with the industry session by session.
Over 25 recorded informations sessions freely available.
AT Awards 2024 ceremony East London October 25th.
Revisiting the AT community at the 2023 awards evening.
The Community Housing Fund and built affordable homes
CLTN reviews the impact of the Fund and calls for extension.
The grading system of the Regulator for Social Housing
A background, an explanation and ten recent enforcements.
Construction, repair and maintenance. Book review.
Putting new life into a city with a 1900 year history.
BSRIA Briefing 2024: Sustainable Futures speakers
Redefining Retrofit for Net Zero Living 22 Nov.
Wall of support for post-Grenfell regulation of electricians
Call for a shake-up of the construction industry highlighted on radio.
Digital sustainability through future AEC tools
Bringing together industry and academia to meet challenges.
Skills gap for net zero highlighted to Minister for Industry
ECA convenes roundtable discussion at Portcullis House.
Evidencing Net Zero with the new UK buildings standard
Pilot version with detailed excel proforma out now!
Scottish Building Safety Levy, in consultation
From direct remediation and the RPDT, to the costs and alternatives.
Waves of warmer homes grants for the rental sector
Boosting energy efficiency standards for all rented homes.
A refocus of the National Planning Policy Framework
Key terms described in brief, as the consultation closes the evening of the 24th.
Fortified farmhouses of the unruly 16th-and 17th-century borders.